Yankees fans witnessed a rare sight on May 4th, 2024, at Yankee Stadium. Aaron Judge, the reigning American League MVP and team captain, was ejected from a game for the first time in his entire professional baseball career. This came during a close game against the Detroit Tigers, with the Yankees eventually securing a 5-3 victory.

Judge, known for his composure and leadership, argued a close call from home plate umpire Ryan Blakney in the seventh inning. After a full count, a fastball from Tigers pitcher Tyler Holton was called strike three, which Judge vehemently disagreed with. While replays showed the pitch was borderline, Judge’s initial reaction was a glance and a walk away. However, something must have been said as he headed back to the dugout, as Blakney swiftly ejected him.

This ejection holds significance for a couple of reasons. Firstly, it breaks an incredible streak for Judge. Having played in over 870 major league games, he had never been tossed before. This speaks volumes about his temperament and respect for umpires, even in frustrating situations.

Secondly, Judge became the first Yankees captain to be ejected since Don Mattingly in 1994. This adds a historical layer to the event, highlighting the rarity of such an occurrence for the team’s leader.

While the exact words spoken by Judge during his brief argument remain undisclosed, crew chief Alan Porter did confirm that Judge “said something he shouldn’t have said.” It’s a reminder that even the most composed players can have their moments of frustration, especially when a close call impacts a tight game.

Despite the ejection, the Yankees were able to hold on for the win. Nevertheless, this event will likely be remembered as a turning point in Judge’s career. It signifies the end of a remarkable streak and showcases that even the most patient players have a limit.